Blame It On The Europeans
Soumaya Ghannoushi, a researcher in the history of ideas at the School of Oriental & African Studies, University of London, says the cartoons are nothing more than 21st century Islamophobia with roots in the medieval European mind:
In the tense post September 11th climate, with its pre-emptive strikes, growing military interventions and increasingly powerful right-wing parties, the medieval arsenal of fantasies and stereotypes of Islam and Muslims has been brought back to life. Gone are the devils and Antichrists of medieval legends and polemics.Ghannoushi engages in a bit of projecting as well, glossing over Muslim atrocities while positing European hostility as the cause of controversy, distrust, and violence:
But their bleak outlook on Islam and the Muslim lingers on unchanged. It survives in an essentialist self-enclosed discourse centred on a mythical pure self permanently pitted against an imaginary dehumanised, demonised Muslim other.
In the past as in the present, religion, culture and the politics of fear are placed at the service of the great games of dominance and mastery.
Make no mistake about it: This is a political conflict that speaks in the language of culture and religion. The conflict is not between "we" and "they", not between cultures and civilisations, but within the same cultural and political front.
The battle must be fought, a battle against intolerance, hatred, myth of cultural superiority and will to hegemony over the other.
It is no coincidence that the cartoons were published in Denmark in a right-wing paper under a right-wing government then reprinted in countries notorious for their hostility to their Muslim minorities and opposition to the cultural and racial diversity of today’s European societies.A Western education and a position at a British university certainly qualify as evidence of European racism and xenophobia. Of course, she is doing nothing more than regurgitating Edward Said's Orientalism and asserting that whatever Muslims have done over the centuries, it is always Europe's fault. How's that for an "us" versus "them" argument?
That reactions to the cartoons have been so passionate should come as no surprise to anyone who has been following developments in the Muslim world closely. To Muslims, the caricatures vividly brought back the scenes of Israeli bulldozers demolishing Palestinian homes in Jenin, the invasion of Afghanistan, the fall of Baghdad, terrors of Abu Ghraib and humiliations of Guantanamo Bay.
Cultural arrogance was added to political aggressiveness. Muslims have grown used to the torrent of terrifying images that associate them and their faith with the most horrifying of practices, from violence and cruelty to fanaticism and oppression. When it comes to Islam, all boundaries and limits could be dispensed with. The unacceptable becomes perfectly acceptable, proper and respectable.
The truth is that today racism, intolerance, xenophobia, and hatred of the other hide behind the sublime façade of free speech, the defence of “our” values and protection of “our” society from “foreign” aggression.